We hosted a “seafood send-off” the night before my in-laws winged their way back to California. I like to tease my mother-in-law about the blandness of San Francisco’s crabmeat while I’ll stuff her stomach with Maryland Blue. And since free food was being served, our children somehow appeared on our doorstep.
My grandson was also in attendance – bringing with him the kind of foul mood only a two-year-old can muster – wanting absolutely nothing to do with this party.
‘Hi Justin – how about a hug for grandpa?’
“No!”
‘Justin, come sit with grandma.’
“No!”
‘Justin, do you want some crab cake?’
“No!”
‘Justin, how about a nice, swift kick in the ass?’
There. I said it. Rhetorical, yes, because I didn’t actually say that to the grouchy little fart. But man, I was sure thinking it.
And then I reflected upon the manner in which my father dispensed discipline. If my elbows were on the dinner table, he wouldn’t request that I remove them; he would simply reach over and knock said elbows from the table.
Temper tantrums and backtalk had a way of making it hurt to sit down for an hour after the infraction. Lack of respect for adults – specifically teachers – meant long weeks of bedroom confinement in addition to the sudden inability to sit comfortably.
I once saw a comedian who riffed on being sent to ‘your room’ as punishment, and then reveling in being confined to the area of the house that contained all his best stuff (toys, music, TV, etc).
Not in my house. As a result of one infraction (can’t recall which – they were rather numerous, especially when I chose to major in being an idiot in the ninth grade), my father invaded my habitat unannounced, rummaged through my personal belongings, and confiscated my stereo system without uttering a word. Yep, dad was light years ahead of today’s airport security tactics.
Out of curiosity, a quick Google of ‘child discipline’ took me to web sites that featured cute terminology like “The Natural Child Project,” “Managing Noncompliant Behavior” and my fave, “The Big List of Consequences.”
I recall my mother sharing a story about her mother’s ‘big list of consequences.’ My sweet, loving grandmother not only doled out punishment with a switch from a backyard tree, but also made the offending offspring cut their own whipping stick.
American society has become much more civilized (hahahahahaha) in the years since my mother dodged the horseless carriage to fetch the dreaded beating branch. Today, parents discipline with politeness, inconsequential threats and inconsistency. And it’s that last one that we often find at the root of defiant child behavior.
Anyway, while we were reveling in our crab and Coronas, Justin strolled through our living room and landed an unprovoked right hook on my mother-in-law. As impressed as I may have been with the strength behind that haymaker, I cringed in anticipation of the boy’s soon-to-be-crimson hindquarters.
Instead, I watched my son-in-law repeatedly pick the child up and sit him on the sofa. Jay would hoist him and plop him and explain why he was being subjected to a ‘time out.’ Justin would then slide down so both feet were back on the floor, crying a bit louder with each slither. The scene was repeated at least a dozen times before order was restored.
I won’t comment further on how the scenario ended, lest I sound as if I’m passing judgment on their parenting skills.
As a grandparent, I view my role in the disciplinarian process along the lines of an English nobleman-type. A lord of the manor who, upon being subjected to repulsive societal behavior by some grubby peasant, simply utters: “Seize him,” “Flog him” or “Bring me his head!”
But I will say that my daughter and son-in-law felt a tad mortified that their son had behaved that way toward a respected family elder who was meeting the child for the first time.
And I will give my son-in-law kudos for having the patience to repetitively enforce the yo-yo-ing time out that unfolded before us. Parental consistency is indeed the key.
If they continue to teach the child to respect the authority of adults and repeatedly demonstrate the consequences of disrespect and bad behavior, then perhaps little Justin will never find himself the recipient of the aforementioned swift kick.
I, however, am in line for one serious whuppin’ once mom reads that ‘horseless carriage’ joke.
By J. Doug Gill